A Kitchen Remodel Five Years in the Making

I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this website.

modern kitchen with hex tile, white cabinets, butcher block countertops, and stainless steel appliances

My kitchen renovation has somewhat been in progress (on and off) for about five years now – a few months after we moved in we painted everything white and put it some semi-permanent updates, but we knew that we had a lot more work to do.

That work included ripping up the linoleum and tiling the floor, updating the ceiling fan, replacing the windows, refinishing the original wood doors to the basement and backyard, and buying new appliances before it finally feels done!

trend mls before image
Before: Listing photos from the house before we moved in

A few months after we moved in, we made a few basic updates to clean up the kitchen while we worked on other projects – like painting all the walls with high-hiding white primer and ceilings a flat white, painting the cabinets and cabinet hardware, re-tiling the backsplash and floating a plywood veneer floor over the linoleum.

We also painted the backdoor white (it had serious damage and gouges and needed to be refinished – but this was a “quick wins” refresh) and built an industrial shelving unit for storage.

At this point, everything at least felt clean and fresh – there was a new coat of paint on just about every surface – but we weren’t prepared to rip up the floors without a plan, which is why we put in the plywood plank floor to cover up the linoleum temporarily until we figured out our long-term solution.

bright white kitchen with butcher block countertops
Between: After painting the walls, cabinets, and hardware, re-tiling the backsplash, and putting plywood veneer floors over the linoleum

Years later (5 years later!) we finally worked up the nerve to rip up the floating veneer floors, pull up the linoleum, and prepare to refinish the original wood floors we thought were lurking underneath. But when we pulled the tiles up we realized there wasn’t just one layer of subfloor – but at least two.

Unsure of what was underneath the second layer of subfloor, we decided to tile instead of crossing our fingers and spending another day pulling up flooring (although we’d been considering tile in the kitchen anyway for easy care). We decided on a matte hexagon mosaic tile like I used in our vestibule entryway to match and because it could handle the curve in our floor from the kitchen to the mudroom.

I loved our update to the cabinets with white paint and black hardware but my initial paint job wasn’t holding up – I’d used latex on the cabinets and painted the knobs and pulls – this time around I repainted the cabinets with enamel and replaced with black hardware (instead of painting over hardware).

kitchen with subway tile and butcher block countertops
After: Pulled up the linoleum and tiled the floor, replaced cabinet hardware, repainted cabinets, painted veneer flooring in mudroom, updated appliances and kitchen faucet
trend mls before image
Before: Listing photos from the house before we moved in
modern white kitchen with gas pipe shelving unit
Between: Painted the back door white (had major damage), built pipe and flange shelving unit, replaced mudroom light
kitchen with black tile and wood industrial shelving unit
After: Stripped and refinished the backdoor, tiled the floor, replaced the windows, updated ceiling fan light fixture, repainted the cabinets, and added magnetic strips to create a knife rack

I also went back and refinished the jalousie window door to the backyard – there were plenty of old layers of paint and polyurethane that needed to be sanded off, and scratches and gauges in the door that had to be repaired and sanded down. It took a few summer weekends to get everything off! I used a wood stain in honey to get close to the color of the countertops and basement door and sealed the door with spar urethane.

While I was stripping and refinishing the door, I also removed and cleaned out the jalousie windows and painted the metal with Rust-Oleum’s All Surface Spray Paint in oil rubbed bronze (my favorite spray paint for just about everything).

before image of a home from trend mls
kitchen with butcher block countertops and stainless steel appliances
kitchen with butcher block countertops and baskets above countertops
kitchen with butcher block countertops and stainless steel appliances

I also recently reorganized my spice rack to make better use of the space – I was able to find some glass bottles with cork stoppers that fit pretty perfectly in the shelves – each shelf fits 15 jars which leaves me with room for 60 jars.

My new labelmaker has definitely been the hero of reorganizing the kitchen – I used it for labeling my spices as well as labeling all of the glass jars we store grains, noodles, cereals, and snacks inside the cabinets as well. I used to have a traditional DYMO embossing labeler but it always seemed to miss the spacing between letters.

modern kitchen with butcher block countertops and subway tile

So – the real question. Is it done?

The answer is maybe – if you count the mudroom as part of the kitchen, then no. There’s still plenty of work to do (like a powder room hopefully)! But the kitchen is about as close to complete I think any room in my house ever gets.

Source List

Paint + Fixtures

Walls: Valspar Bistro White 7006-4 in eggshell
Trim: Valspar Ultra White 7006-24 in semi-gloss
Ceilings: BEHR® Ultra Pure White ceiling flat interior paint
Cabinets: BEHR® urethane alkyd satin enamel
Ceiling fan: Monte Carlo Discus II 44″ ceiling fan
Back door stain: MinWax Wood Finish Interior Penetrating Stain in honey
Back door sealant: MinWax Helmsman Spar Urethene in clear satin
Back door metal paint: Rust-Oleum Universal All Surface Spray Paint in oil rubbed bronze metallic


Backsplash: Snow White glossy 2×4 subway tile
Floor: Merola metro hex matte black porcelain mosaic tile


Refrigerator: Samsung counter-depth french door refrigerator
Range: Samsung freestanding gas range
Dishwasher: Bosch built-in full console dishwasher
Microwave: Samsung over-the-range microwave
Toaster: Cuisinart bakery artisan bread long toaster

Shop the Room

woven basket
Household Essentials

Water hyacinth wicker storage basket

marble mortar and pestle

Marble footed mortar and pestle

black cup drawer handle

Flat black cabinet cup drawer handle

long bread toaster

Bakery artisan bread long toaster

six seasons cookbook
Joshua McFadden

Six Seasons: A new way with vegetables

white subway tile
Mission Stone & Tile

Snow white glossy 2×4 subway tile

salt fat acid heat cookbook
Samin Nosrat

Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat: Mastering the elements of good cooking

glass and cork spice jar

Glass spice jars with cork stoppers and black square stickers

delta kitchen faucet
Delta Faucet

Pilar 2-handle widespread kitchen sink faucet with side sprayer

ikea glass bottle

Korken glass bottle with stopper

black hexagon mosaic tile

Metro hex matte black porcelain mosaic tile

plenty cookbook
Yotam Ottolenghi

Plenty: Vibrant vegetable recipes


Lighting Ideas For Rooms Without Ceiling Lights

Our home was built in 1875 - like a lot of homes with that much history, ours...

How to Hack IKEA Pax into a Built-In Closet

Anyone who lives in Philadelphia is familiar with the closet situation here - most of the houses are 100+ years old and either don't...

How to Make a Freestanding Industrial Gas Pipe Shelf

The last project in our kitchen rehab was one that I'd planned from the start - a...

10 Fridge Organization Ideas & Storage Tricks

I love organizing my fridge. Pulling everything out, giving everything a good clean, and then carefully finding...



20 Best Cleaning Supply Caddies & Totes

Cleaning caddies can be found in many different materials and styles - but the best cleaning caddies for you might not be...

How to Stock & Organize Your Cleaning Caddy

Even if you don't love cleaning, being in a clean house can reduce stress and boost your...

Wedding Portraits at Iceland’s Raufarhólshellir Lava Tunnel

Our day in the Reykjanes was unforgettable - from ice caves and sea cliffs to geothermal vents and lava fields. We started off by...

Seltún & Gunnuhver Geothermal Fields in Iceland

The geothermal fields were otherworldly, volatile, and apocalyptic - with soil and mud ranging from white to blue to bright yellow and red, bubbling,...